Pantry + Gourmet Food

Filter
    Shop our best-selling collection of gourmet foods! If you don't see an item online that you have purchased in the past from our store, give us a call at the store to see if it's in store!
    Maple Brown Sugar Oatmeal
    $13.99
    Sold Out
    Mustard Tree Collection Holiday 2024
    $22.99
    Orange Cranberry Marmalade
    $9.99
    Sold Out
    Pepper Jelly Holiday Collection 2024
    $24.99
    Sold Out
    Holiday Salsa Collection 2024
    $39.99
    Sold Out
    Holiday Sampler Collection 2024
    $39.99
    Sold Out
    Holiday Dessert Sauce Collection 2024
    $24.99
    Cranberry Pistachio Biscotti Crisps
    $9.50
    Cranberry Horseradish Sauce
    $9.50
    Sold Out
    Cinnamon Apple Syrup
    $9.99
    Chili Starter
    $11.99
    Sold Out
    Dye-Free Jingle Pop! Nonpareils
    $9.50
    Sold Out
    Plant-Based Food Colors - Holiday Colors
    $11.99
    Sold Out
    Dye-Free Snowfall Sprinkles
    $9.50
    Sold Out
    Dye-Free Christmas Softies Sprinkles, 3oz
    $9.50
    Plant-Based Food Colors
    $11.99
    Dye-Free Rainbow Pop! Nonpareil Sprinkles, 3oz
    $9.50
    Sold Out
    Peach Berry Jalapeno, 5 oz
    $7.99
    Raspberry Jalapeño, 5 oz
    $7.99
    Mixed Berry Jalapeno, 5 oz
    $7.99
    Montana Creekside Classic Chili Mix
    $8.99
    Sold Out
    Torani Lavender Syrup
    $16.99
    Sold Out
    Holiday Hot Cocoa Kit
    $12.99
    Spicy Guac Snack Mix, 6oz Pouch
    $9.99
    Sold Out
    Naked Turtle Mix, 8oz
    $11.99
    Sold Out
    Caramel Brownie Mix, 8oz
    $11.99
    Sold Out
    Rocking Chair Mix, 6.5oz
    $11.99
    Sold Out
    5 O'clock Crunch Snowman Holiday Label, 14oz Tin
    $16.99
    Sold Out
    Milk Chocolate Peanuts Holiday Snowman Label, 11oz
    $14.99
    Sold Out
    Snowman Holiday Label Salted Virginia Peanuts
    from $8.99
    Sold Out
    Snowy Chocolate Popcorn
    from $8.99
    Sold Out
    Old School Brand: Mulling Spice Packet
    $7.99
    Old School Brand: Peppermint Stick Candy
    $12.99
    Sold Out
    Old School Brand: Santa Claus Hot Cocoa
    $12.99
    Sold Out
    Old School Brand: White Chocolate Hot Cocoa
    $12.99
    Sold Out
    Floral Candy Cane Cocoa
    $9.99
    Sold Out
    Cowboy Christmas Chocolate Cocoa
    $9.99
    Sold Out
    Christmas Deer Sweet Hot Cocoa
    $9.99
    Sold Out
    Winter Warmer Wonderland Red Pickup Hot Cocoa Tin
    $9.99
    Sold Out
    Salted Caramel Cocoa
    $2.50
    Sold Out
    Santa Chocolate Cocoa
    $2.50
    Sold Out
    Christmas Santa's Favorite Chocolate Cocoa
    $2.50
    Sold Out
    Christmas Gingerbread Cookie Cocoa
    $2.50
    Sold Out
    White Christmas Snowman Belgian White Hot Chocolate
    $2.50
    Sold Out
    Christmas Tree Red Velvet Cocoa
    $2.50
    Sold Out
    Vintage Santa Double Chocolate Cocoa
    $2.50
    Sold Out
    Winter Wonderland Dark Chocolate Cocoa
    $2.50
    Cranberry Chili Pecan Preserves
    $10.50
    Sold Out
    Pecan Pie in a Jar
    $21.99
    Sold Out
    Vulcan's Fire Salt
    $11.99
    Lakeshore Shallot and Herb
    $11.99
    Gateway to the North Maple Garlic
    $11.99
    Mexican Chile Lime Seasoning
    $11.99
    Steakhouse Smoke Seasoning
    $11.99
    Back of the Yards Garlic Pepper
    $11.99
    Wild West Huckleberry Jam
    $14.50
    Snackable Red Wine & Rosemary Crackerology Kit
    $11.99
    Sold Out
    Snackable White Wine & Basil Crackerology Kit
    $11.99
    Snackable Jalapeño & Chipotle Crackerology Kit
    $13.99
    Snackable Sweet S'mores Crackerology Kit
    $13.99
    Snackable Lemon Blueberry Crackerology Kit
    $13.99
    Appalachian Trail Cornbread Mix
    $6.99
    Sold Out
    Virginia Blue Ridge Broccoli Cheddar Soup Mix
    $8.99
    Torani Sugar Free Black Cherry Syrup
    $16.99
    Sold Out
    Torani Sugar Free Vanilla Syrup
    $16.99
    Sold Out
    Torani Sugar Free Pumpkin Pie Syrup
    $16.99
    Torani Sugar Free English Toffee Syrup
    $16.99
    Torani Sugar Free Caramel Syrup
    $16.99
    Sold Out
    Torani Vanilla Syrup
    $16.99
    Sold Out
    Torani Lemon Syrup
    $16.99
    Torani Strawberry Syrup
    $16.99
    Torani Red Raspberry Syrup
    $16.99
    Torani Pumpkin Pie Syrup
    $16.99
    Sold Out
    Torani Hazelnut Syrup
    $16.99
    Torani English Toffee Syrup
    $16.99
    Torani Coconut Syrup
    $16.99
    Sold Out
    Torani Caramel Syrup
    $16.99
    Torani Amaretto Syrup
    $16.99
    Torani Peanut Butter Syrup
    $16.99
    Torani Peach Syrup
    $16.99