Pantry + Gourmet Food

Filter
    Shop our best-selling collection of gourmet foods! If you don't see an item online that you have purchased in the past from our store, give us a call at the store to see if it's in store!
    Spices + Rubs
    Jelly + Jam + Honey
    Salsa + Sauce + Dressing
    Hot + Cold Dip Mixes
    Baking Ingredients + Mixes
    Popcorn + Seasoning
    Chocolate + Sweet Treats
    Drink Mixes + Extras
    Pasta + Pizza
    Snacks + Shareables
    To Market To Market Thrill of a Dill Dip Mix
    $6.99
    Torani Sugar Free Vanilla Bean
    $16.99
    Torani Green Apple Syrup
    $16.99
    Organic Durum Wheat Flour (IGP) of Altamura by Molino Camema
    $8.50
    Organic Soft Wheat "00" Flour of Altamura by Molino Camema
    $8.50
    La Rustica Passata di Pomodoro Tomato Puree
    $7.99
    Greek Isle Falafel Chips
    $7.50
    Roasted Red Pepper & Feta Dip
    $10.50
    Cilantro Lime Ranch Dressing
    $9.50
    Jalapeno Corn Bread Crackers
    $6.95
    Hot Pepper Berry Bacon Jam
    $10.50
    Hot Honey BBQ Sauce
    $17.99
    Honey Mustard BBQ Sauce
    $17.99
    Sweet Honey BBQ Sauce
    $17.99
    Thai Chili Sriracha
    $10.50
    Torani Sugar Free Salted Caramel
    $16.99
    Sold Out
    Torani Blue Raspberry Syrup
    $16.99
    Snackable Ready For Confetti Kit
    $13.99
    Jack's Spicy Gourmet Seasoning
    $14.99
    Hot Honey Chili Virginia Peanuts, 9oz Tin
    $9.99
    Honey Cheddar 5 O'Clock Crunch, 6oz Tin
    $9.99
    Dye-Free Dinomite Sprinkles
    $9.50
    Dye-Free Rainbow Starfetti Sprinkles
    $9.50
    Dye-Free Unicorn Tracks Sprinkles
    $9.50
    Dye-Free Rainbow Softies Sprinkles
    $9.50
    Torani Sugar Free Strawberry Syrup
    $16.99
    Torani Sugar Free Raspberry Syrup
    $16.99
    Torani Cherry Syrup
    $16.99
    Potato Gnocchi with Corn (Gluten-Free) Pasta by Le Veneziane
    $10.50
    Hot Pepper Cranberry Jelly
    $10.50
    10 oz. Satsuma Pepper Fruit Preserves for Cheese
    Satsuma Pepper Fruit Preserves for Cheese, 10oz
    $11.99
    Sold Out
    10 oz. Blueberry Lemon Thyme Fruit Preserves for Cheese
    Blueberry Lemon Thyme Fruit Preserves for Cheese, 10oz
    $11.99
    Sold Out
    4.4 oz. Multigrain Wheat Crackers
    Multigrain Wheat Crackers
    $6.99
    4.5 oz. Loukanika Salumi
    Loukanika Salumi
    $14.99
    4.5 oz. Chorizo Salumi
    Chorizo Salumi
    $14.99
    14.5 oz. Teriyaki BBQ Sauce
    Teriyaki BBQ Sauce, 14.5oz
    $10.99
    14 oz. Stout BBQ Sauce
    Stout BBQ Sauce, 14oz
    $10.99
    12 oz. Honey Mustard Dressing
    Honey Mustard Dressing, 12oz
    $10.99
    10 oz. Jalapeño Stout Mustard
    Jalapeño Stout Mustard, 10oz
    $12.99
    10 oz. Lemon Curd Sauce
    Lemon Curd Sauce, 10oz
    $12.99
    10 oz. Raspberry Fudge Sauce
    Raspberry Fudge Sauce, 10oz
    $13.99
    10 oz. Bourbon + Butter Caramel Sauce
    Bourbon + Butter Caramel Sauce, 10oz
    $13.99
    5 oz. Orange Habanero Hot Sauce
    Orange Habanero Hot Sauce, 5oz
    $8.99
    Kick in the Pants Seasoning
    $16.99
    Fancy Shmancy Seasoning
    $16.99
    Effortless Apple Bourbon Pulled Pork Starter
    $17.99
    Carnitas Seasoning
    $7.99
    Jamaican Jerk Seasoning
    $7.99
    Nashville Hot Seasoning
    $7.99
    Effortless Mole Sauce Starter
    $13.99
    Sold Out
    Parmesan Truffle Couscous
    $13.99
    Effortless Orange Chicken Starter
    $16.99
    Effortless Tikka Masala Starter
    $16.99
    Effortless Carnitas Starter
    $16.99
    Peach + Onion Hot Sauce
    $8.99
    Cranberry Walnut Relish
    $10.99
    Smoked Whiskey Glaze
    $12.99
    Champagne Honey Mustard
    $12.99
    Mesquite Horseradish Mustard
    $12.99
    Smoked Tomato Truffle Jam
    $10.99
    Bacon + Apple Jam
    $10.99
    Sweet + Savory Sweet Bourbon Grillin Sauce
    $10.99
    Effortless Chimichurri Sauce Mix
    $12.99
    Truffle Parmesan + Black Garlic Seasoning
    $8.50
    Sold Out
    Noble Mick's Frozen Espresso Martini
    $17.99
    Sold Out
    Noble Mick's Frozen Peach Bellini
    $17.99
    Noble Mick's Frozen Margarita
    $17.99
    Noble Mick's Frosé Frozen Cocktail
    $17.99
    Sold Out
    Junket Ice Cream Mix
    $7.99
    Sold Out
    Bourbon Barrel Foods Chocolate Box - Assorted 9 piece
    $24.99
    Bourbon Smoked Spiced Pecans
    $18.99
    Woodford Reserve Aged Cherry Bitters
    $13.50
    Woodford Reserve Orange Bitters
    $13.50
    Honey Cheddar 5 O'Clock Crunch, 6oz Tin, Holiday Label
    $9.99
    Sold Out
    Woodford Reserve Old Fashioned Cocktail Syrup
    $21.99
    Sold Out
    Salted Caramel Infused Maple Syrup
    $27.99
    Sold Out
    WhistlePig Rye Whiskey Barrel-Aged Organic Maple Syrup
    $39.99
    Cocktail Mixer Collection
    $34.99
    Sold Out
    LIMITED RELEASE Snow Globe Sparkle Syrup®
    $27.99
    Cinnamon + Vanilla Infused Maple Syrup
    $27.99